Thursday, January 23, 2014

Outline of Sam Harris’s talk titled “It is always now” and my commentary

Death – all try to avoid death. But human adults all know about mortality. We know that we can be or have been suddenly given the full time job of engaging in active dying or fighting death in ourselves or someone we love.
What most people ask of themselves at such times is “how have I spent my time?” Most judge that they have misspent their time and cared about the wrong sort of things. Although we know such an epiphany inducing moment is imminent, we tend to live like we live forever.
There are ways to live in the moment (bring high value to the time we experience). It is a reality of our mental life that it is always NOW.
Caveats: It is not now in the visible universe (what we experience as now occurred in some cases 13.5 billion years ago) and not now in neurological or neurochemical understanding (it takes a minimum of tens of milliseconds to process and register a perception). However it is a liberating truth about our own minds that can make us happy [wrong word i.e. that we can attribute as worthwhile -- time well spent – leading to increased wellbeing and mental equilibrium]. Past memories are thoughts arising presently and likewise the “future” is a thought arising now. We forget this truth, and succeed in fooling ourselves by looking over our shoulders and attaching undue value to a memory [that is usually deeply flawed] or give time to the illusion of what is coming next [Luke 12:27 "Consider how the wild flowers grow. They do not labor or spin. Yet I tell you, not even Solomon in his splendor was dressed like one of these.”]
To enjoy [wrong word i.e. optimize the mental construct of our existence] whatever is true of life in the present requires a change in both attitude and awareness to experience each now, each present moment fully.

JRH Commentary – When we undergo the transformation in attribution, attitude, and awareness like Harris’s puts forward the moral stakes change. And I don’t mean we cannot and must not make reasoned global judgments about the gains or losses that arise throughout the transition, but I believe that a discipline/practice/focus on being fully present with each moment we are granted is, on balance, a boon to our wellbeing.

It is not without costs. Engaging in this practice changes our viable options. This truth holds for any and all disciplines, e.g. going to church regularly, daily devotions, playing a musical instrument, regular physical exercise, paddling along IN rivers. Unexpected consequences or hidden outcomes are unpredictable but may include the following: you falsely attribute present pain with future gain; you forgo unfettered Sunday mornings when you could do chores or surf the web; you selfishly sequester time for yourself on a piano bench or in a canoe away from other high priority activities or venues such as wife, family, internet, etc. So being in the eternal present can bring with it subjectivism, hedonism, self-centeredness, and a collapse of the transcendent – but it needn’t do that. Reflective practice can bring awareness to the conditions of our awareness and can make the “invisible” [things we are blind to] manifest.

When applying invectives like hedonistic, airy fairy, selfish, etc. it seems to me we paint a time-tested option for spiritual formation with an overly broad negative bias. Isn’t the “bottom-line” of Christian spiritual practice your worthiness in Gods sight? Practicing eternal presence means that in each and every moment we are given the opportunity to breathe in grace and each acknowledged heart beat gives life irrespective of our striving. You now are everything that is!

“All this universe to the furthest stars
all beyond them is your flesh, your fruit [your NOW]
Take your practiced powers and stretch them out
until they span the chasm between two
contradictions …. For god wants
to know himself in you”   Rilke